Call us now ! Send us an email 1/2 N Beaver St Lisbon United States

Back to Top

Call Us Today!
(330) 424-3559
Call Us Today!
(330) 424-3559


How Mary’s Started

Mary’s Pizza Shop has a history. And the grandsons of the original owners are making history. The pizza shop was opened in 1961 in the home of Carmen and Mary Spadero. Grandson Steve Garofalo says his mom, grandfather and Aunt Marge helped his grandmother get started and it took off right away. In 1985, Steve and his brother, Mike, took over the business. Often, there were waiting lists of up to two and a half hours for the popular pizza attracting customers from as far away as Alliance, Canfield and East Liverpool, encompassing Stark, Mahoning and Columbiana counties. Over the winter months, Carmen’s garage next door was converted to a new and larger pizza shop, which is the current location. Today, as in years past, the pizza is all homemade from scratch from Mary’s old recipes: Fresh tomatoes and tomato paste, Fresh homemade dough for the crust, 300 pounds of fried sausage per week for the sauce, 8 oz. of cheese and 13-15 oz. of sausage heaped on a 12-inch pie. In addition to its great homemade taste, the shop maintains a loyal customer base and continues to draw patrons from a large area. Being one of the first pizza shops in the area, Steve says they still get a lot of customers that came in 1961.

Inquire about franchises within Call Mary’s at 330-424-3559 


Jalapeno Poppers
Ripe jalapeno stuffed with cheddar cheese

Fried Cheese Sticks

Fried Mushroom

Fried Onion Rings

Small Sampler
Two jalapeno poppers, two cheese sticks with sauce and eith wings (BBQ, Cajun, Garlic, or Hot)
Large Sampler
Four jalapeno poppers, Four cheese sticks with sauce and eight wings (BBQ, Cajun, Garlic, or Hot)
Choose BBQ, Cajun, Garlic or Hot, made with our own sauces
Chicken Strips
All white meat with dipping sauce (BBQ, Cajun, Garlic or Hot)

Menu Items Subject to Change
Your pizza can be made with your choice of sauces and crusts and can be frozen for you to cook at home. Choose from:
Mary's Original Sauce- A blend of tomatoes, herbs, garlic and ground sausage in a hearty slightly sweet sauce. 

Mary's Marinara- A meatless version of Mary's Original Sauce.

Whole Tomato Sauce- Chunks of ripe tomatoes simmered with olive oil, garlic and spices for a rustic Italian flavor. Covered with Provolone and Romano cheeses plus your choice of toppings. 
White Pizza- Romano and Provolone cheese, olive oil, herbs, & spices and the toppings of your choice. 
Thick or Thin Crust- Either way you choose, our pizza dough is made fresh daily according to Mary's original recipe. 

Please note: All Mary's Pizzas are made with Mary's Original Sauce(with meat) unless you specify another sauce (marinara, whole tomato, or white). 

Pepperoni & Mushroom
Sausage & Pepperoni
Sausage & Mushroom
Sausage, Pepperoni, & Mushroom
Mushroom & Onion
Mushroom & Green Pepper
BBQ Chicken NEW!
Green Peppers, Onions, Black Olives, Hot Peppers.
Extra Pepperoni, Sausage
Extra Cheese or cheese to go
Pepperoni Roll
Filled with provolone cheese, pepperoni and Mary's Sauce


Ask about Wing Trays!

  • Party Focaccia
  • Party Chef's Salad
  • Party Grilled Chicken


Our sandwiches feature our own freshly baked breads and rolls, and are served with potato chips. Grinders and focaccia taste great with our house mayonnaise in four flavors - Basil, Hot Pepper, Roasted Garlic or Regular - or with our house Italian dressing. 
Focaccia Sandwiches
With Provolone cheese
Our version of focaccia (foe-KAH-cha), the classic Italian flatbread, makes any sandwich delicious. Choose from Grilled Herb Chicken Breast, Smoked Turkey, Smoked Ham or Roast Beef. Each is served with lettuce, tomato and red onion slices and your choice of Regular, Basil, Hot Pepper, or Garlic Mayonnaise, or our house Italian dressing. 
Muffaletta Sandwich
Salami, pepperoni, ham & cheese, served hot on a fresh-baked bun with our special muffaletta (moo-fah-LET-tah) Italian olive topping.
Mini Pepperoni Roll
A lunch-sized version of Mary's famous pepperoni roll, filled with lots of pepperoni, sauce and Provolone cheese. Great for fund-raisers!
Italian Sub
With Provolone cheese
Made the old-fashioned way with salami, pepperoni, baked ham, lettuce, tomato and red onion on a fresh hoagie bun. Top with your choice of flavored mayonnaise or house Italian dressing. 
Fish Sandwich
With Provolone cheese
With Provolone cheese
Served on a fresh-baked hoagie bun with lettuce, tomato, red onion and your choice of flavored mayonnaise or house Italian dressing. Choose from Grilled Herb Chicken Breast, Smoked Turkey, Smoked Ham or Roast Beef. 
Classic Sausage Sandwich
DiRusso's link sausage on a fresh hoagie bun with grilled peppers, onions, provolone cheese and Mary's marinara sauce. 
Classic Meatball Sandwich
Three of our homemad meatballs topped with Mary's marinara sauce and lots of Provolone cheese



Large Grilled Chicken Salad
Small Grilled Chicken Salad

Herb-marinated breast of chicken, grilled and served on a mix of lettuce, tomato, green pepper, red onion and provolone cheese. Choose from French, Racnch, Blue Cheese, Sweet 'n Sour, Lite Italian or house Italian dressing. 
Large Chef's Salad
Small Chef's Salad
A variation of the traditional Chef's salad with pepperoni, black olives, lettuce, tomato, green pepper, red onion, and provolone cheese, plus your choice of French, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Sweet 'n Sour, Lite Italian or house Italian dressing. 
Large Toss Salad
Small Toss Salad

Lettuce, tomato, green pepper, red onion and provolone cheese, plus your choice of French, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Sweet 'n Sour, Lite Italian or house Italian dressing

Homemade Wedding Soup (fall and winter only)


Lunch Pizza-- Plain or One Topping


Additional Toppings 30 cents each
Our 8" version of Mary's famous pizza. Available with Mary's regular or marinara sauce and your choice of toppings and ready in about 10 minutes. (Large pizzas are available for lunch order, but allow at least 40 minutes.)


Build Your Own Wrap (Avalible All Day)
 Served with your choice of meat, cheese, and vegetables wrapped in a tortilla and grilled to your liking.

Lunch served Tuesday-Friday
10:30 AM-1 PM
Phone orders taken after 9 AM

PANNINIS... grilled to perfection!

​Philly Pannini
Sliced roast beef, grilled peppers and onions and provolone cheese in between Mary's Italian flatbread
Cordon Bleu Pannini
Sliced chicken and ham, provolone cheese, layered between Mary's Italian flatbread. 
Chicken and Cheese Pannini
Sliced chicken, provolone cheese and roasted red pepper layerd between Mary's Italian flatbread
Vegetarian Pannini
Roasted red pepper, black olives, provolone cheese, mushrooms and fresh onion and tomato layered between Mary's Italian flatbread
Italian Pannini
Sliced pepperoni, salami, ham provolone cheese and roasted red pepper layered between Mary's classic Italian flatbread. 
Ham and Cheese Pannini
Sliced ham, provolone cheese, and tomatoes layered between Mary's Italian flatbread